The Best Mattress Protector to Put on Your Bed

smaill teddy bear resting on top of the best mattress protectorimage source: Pixabay

You’ve already invested in a great mattress, and you want it to last for a long time, so you need to figure out how to protect it. Whether you have small children that will undoubtedly spill something on their bed at some point or you’re just trying to take extra steps to ensure longevity in your mattress, the cheap $6 mattress cover at the grocery store just won’t cut it: so what will? What is the best mattress protector?

Not only will we answer this question, but we will also go over what makes the best mattress protector, exploring what features make a mattress protector high-quality, long-lasting, and capable of providing adequate coverage. We’ll compare a variety of options and look into the important specs and features, so by the end of this article you should have a clear picture of which options will work for your needs.

Mattress Protector FAQs

The best mattress protector will have a few important features, but what you need may vary depending on some other criteria. Look at the following questions and answers before diving into our comparison and review to make sure you’re choosing the right mattress protector for your needs.

1. What Is the Best Mattress Protector?

There are some that will rise above others in terms of the best mattress protector, but there isn’t a number-one option overall that will fit everyone’s needs. We will cover our top choices at the end of the article to avoid giving bias upfront, however, we recommend reading through these questions to understand what you do and don’t need from a mattress protector.

2. What Type of Fit Do I Need?

There are three different mattress pads in terms of fit: fitted, elastic strap, and zippered. Fitted mattress protectors work and look a lot like a fitted sheet and are just as easy (or difficult, as some of us struggle with the corners) to put on and take off for cleaning. You also must get a mattress protector that fits with the pocket size of your mattress, as some will have deeper or more shallow pockets.

Having elastic straps as a fit option eliminates some fit issues like the pocket size. There are elastic straps that will fit over the corners of the mattress to secure it. Some people have a harder time using the straps because they don’t cover the corners as completely and can get a little rumpled if they’re not tight.

A zippered mattress protector covers the entire mattress—top and bottom. This is a good option for those needing complete protection from more than just spills. The fit will be more specific like the fitted protector, so be sure you know your mattress and pocket size when buying.

3. What Type of Protection Do I Want?

There are a few options to consider in terms of what the protector works against as well as basic coverage and material. You may know what you need overall, but have a few boxes you’d like checked by the features.

Mattress protectors that work against dust mites are popular. Dust mites feed on skin and can be an irritant or allergen, so having a layer dedicated to protecting against them is a big plus for many people. These mattress protectors will feature small pores to create a comprehensive barrier against dust mites.

Waterproof protectors are another common option. Whether it’s for small children or just to protect the mattress from sweating during sleep, these are often a handy form of protection that will trap moisture and keep it away from the mattress.

A bed bug protector is typically only needed for specialized circumstances. It is much thicker than other options and zips completely around the mattress to protect it from bed bugs entering and nesting.

4. What Other Features Should I Look for?

Beyond the questions above, the best mattress protectors will offer additional features. It is important to see what’s out there before you buy, so you can be confident you are getting the best mattress protector for you and your family.

Many of the best mattress protectors are hypoallergenic. You may think this will only matter to people who suffer from allergies, but even if you’re not one of those people, a hypoallergenic mattress protector is still desirable; they are free from potentially harmful chemicals and help prevent dust mites and the growth of mold and bacteria.

Pay attention to the pore size. The standard pore size is about 8 microns, but the lower that number is, the more effective the mattress protector will be at preventing things like bugs, dust, dandruff, or moisture from getting through.

Ideally, your mattress protector will be machine washable, but some options are easy to wipe down. What you need is up to you, just be sure to keep an eye out for the style you prefer.

Is the mattress protector breathable? While this may not be a priority for everyone, mattress protector that is breathable will keep you more comfortable at night, reduce the number of times you have to wash it, and ultimately last longer.

5. Where Can I Buy Mattress Protectors?

You can buy mattress protectors in a variety of places, including homeware stores such as Bed Bath & Beyond, big-box stores such as Walmart, or from online marketplaces such as Amazon.com.

How We Reviewed

two pillow on top of the mattress protectorimage source: Pixabay

To keep this review as straightforward and non-biased as possible, we are using the following criteria: features, price, and warranty. We found this method highlights the important features we’ve talked about above and bring to light any potential drawbacks or issues with each option.

It is important to keep in mind that not every option on this list caters to everyone’s needs, as we tried to pull from multiple directions to give the most variable options. This means that there will be a wide variety in terms of build, specificity, and price.

Overall Price Range

While there are definitely low-budget mattress protectors, you’ll typically see more durable and better-performing options depending on quality and specifications. We’ve opted to list prices in terms of budget ranges instead of exact prices, as those are likely to change.

What We Reviewed

  • SureGuard Mattress Encasement
  • SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector
  • LINENSPA Zippered Encasement
  • Utopia Bedding Premium Zippered Waterproof Mattress Encasement
  • LUCID Premium Rayon from Bamboo Jersey Mattress Protector
  • LUCID Premium Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector

SureGuard Mattress Encasement

Queen (13-16 in. Deep) SureGuard Mattress Encasement - 100%...
  • 100% Waterproof - Six-sided premium mattress protector blocks perspiration, bed wetting, liquids and stains; 10-year...
  • Bed Bug Proof - Super fine zipper with Invisi-Zip and SureSeal technology completely seals off the mattress from bed...
  • Hypoallergenic - Blocks dust mites, allergens, bacteria, mildew and mold - use with SureGuard Pillow Protectors
  • About
  • Where to Buy
  • WARRANTY

This is a zippered mattress protector that focuses on water protection. There is also a small pore size, so typical allergens like dust, dandruff, and pollen are protected against, as are dust mites and bed bugs. It is made from a soft material, so it doesn’t feel or sound like you have plastic sheets, which is a common complaint of less expensive mattress protectors. You can throw this mattress protector in your washing machine when it’s time to be cleaned. Users have reported a few issues: the waterproofing isn’t 100% effective, it is difficult to get on to the mattress, and the zipper is small and hard to use.

There is a 10-year warranty for this mattress protector.

SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector

SafeRest King Size Premium Hypoallergenic Waterproof Mattress...
  • Protects Against Dust Mites, Fluids, Urine, Perspiration and Allergens (10-Year Warranty)
  • Hypoallergenic Cotton Terry Surface With Membrane Back Coating (Waterproof, Noiseless and Breathable)
  • Great For Those With Kids, Pets, Allergies, Asthma, Eczema Or Incontinence (OEKO-TEX Certified SH025 151792)

  • About
  • Where to Buy
  • WARRANTY

The SafeRest mattress protector offers well-rounded function; it protects against moisture, allergens, dust mites, bed bugs, and bacteria. It is also a breathable, noiseless option on top of being machine washable. This mattress protector is fitted, which means it cannot completely protect against dust mites or bed bugs. It also stretches after repeated use.

This mattress protector comes with a 10-year warranty.

LINENSPA Zippered Encasement

Linenspa Zippered Waterproof, Dust Mite, Bed Bug Proof, Queen Size...
  • Thin, quiet waterproof barrier protects all six sides of the mattress from fluids and spills vinyl free materials are...
  • Machine washable encasement has a zippered closure for a comfortable secure fit on mattresses up to 12" deep
  • Fully encases your mattress with a smooth, lightweight fabric to form a reliable barrier against bed bugs, dust mites...

  • About
  • Where to Buy
  • Warranty

This is a lightweight, zippered option that will provide waterproofing and protection from dust mites and bed bugs. It is breathable, machine washable, and quiet. It’s great for typical allergens, however, users have reported that it is not as cool as they expect and it retains heat. There are not deep pocket options, so if your mattress is over 12 inches, you may struggle with finding a fit here.

This mattress protector comes with a 10-year warranty.

Utopia Bedding Premium Zippered Waterproof Mattress Encasement

Utopia Bedding Premium 135 GSM Waterproof Mattress Encasement, 360°...
  • MATTRESS ENCASEMENT - Fits Queen sized mattress perfectly with dimensions of 60 by 80 inches, featuring deep fitted...
  • KNITTED POLYESTER - Thick knitted polyester fabric is not only soft and breathable but also highly durable; high-quality...
  • ZIPPERED - Stretchable and secured 360 degrees by a mini-zipper with a zip guard to wrap the mattress completely; it...

  • About
  • Where to Buy
  • Warranty

This mattress protector is a good option if you require multiple forms of protection. It offers a waterproof, zippered build to protect from dust mites and bed bugs. The pocket depth is also adjustable to 15 inches if needed. Finally, it is machine washable, so there’s no special treatment needed. The biggest issue we saw with this mattress protector is that is doesn’t hold up well against urine in particular, though it did fine with sweat and other moisture.

There is no warranty information available for this mattress protector. While there is a return period, the lack of warranty information is a concern.

LUCID Premium Rayon from Bamboo Jersey Mattress Protector

LUCID Premium Rayon from Bamboo Jersey Mattress Protector - Ultra Soft...
  • A premium blend of 70% rayon from bamboo and 30% cotton creates a breathable, ultra-soft, and moisture wicking surface...
  • Beneath the soft fabric surface, our quiet proprietary STRATOSMART barrier protects the top of your mattress from all...
  • Designed to be lightweight so it does not change the feel of your mattress, this secure fitted sheet style protector has...

  • About
  • Where to Buy
  • Warranty

The bamboo feature aids in making this mattress protector more comfortable and quiet. It claims protection against dust mites and allergens; however, as it is a fitted-sheet style, it cannot completely protect against dust mites or allergens, not to mention bed bugs. There are deep, stretchable pockets for a better fit on mattresses with deeper pockets, though a thinner mattress may find this mattress protector does not fit as snuggly as it should.

This mattress protector is waterproof, and the lightweight design helps to increase breathability. The ability to wash it at home in your machine is also a convenient feature. This mattress protector has a lower price than any of the mattress protectors on our list, so far, going even lower than our predicted and researched price points.

This model offers a 15-year warranty to cover manufacturer errors and any malfunctions that occur during that period that can be attributed to more than just normal wear and tear.

LUCID Premium Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector

LUCID Premium Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector -...
  • 100% Waterproof - repels all liquids including bodily fluids, perspiration, urine and accidental spills - machine...
  • Noiseless and comfortable hypoallergenic cotton terry surface and polyurethane backing inhibits allergy-causing dust...
  • Fully-elasticized fitted sheet style with deep pockets designed to fit mattresses up to 22 inches deep

  • About
  • Where to Buy
  • Warranty

This is a fitted-sheet style that offers deep pockets for mattresses that need them (up to 22 inches). It is waterproof and claims to protect against dust mites, bed bugs, and other allergens. However, as this is not a zippered protector, the coverage from dust mites and bed bugs can only be partial. It operates noiselessly, so you won’t be rustled awake by your mattress protector crinkling. This mattress protector is machine washable, but you will have to hang it to dry—putting it in your dryer could ruin it. It is a thinner mattress protector, adding to the breathability, and it can be purchased for an affordable price.

Like the previous Lucid model, you can expect a 15-year warranty to cover any problems related to workmanship, packaging, or manufacturing.

The Verdict: The Best Mattress Protector

mattress with headboard in bedroomimage source: Pixabay

Now that we’ve gone through the facts on mattress protectors and have given you an idea of what combination of features and protection would make the best mattress protector, is there really a number one option overall? In terms of coverage, there is not an absolute winner, as each option had issues. However, we can say he SureGuard and Utopia held up fairly well in that department and outperformed the others on this list.

In terms of the best value, we would direct you towards either of the Lucid options, as they both cater towards slightly different needs and are the most affordable options here.

While we can’t predict what the best mattress protector for your home will be, we hope our comparison and subsequent suggestions of the best mattress protector will help you make the optimal choice for your home.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *